question
Powers of Local Government
answer
- tax/be taxed
- sue/be sued
- enter into contracts
- acquire, hold, dispose of money
- take on debt
- eminent domain
- acquire, hold, and dispose of personal property
- sue/be sued
- enter into contracts
- acquire, hold, dispose of money
- take on debt
- eminent domain
- acquire, hold, and dispose of personal property
question
Dylan's Rule
answer
locality can exercise three types of power:
1. delegated powers from legislature
2. implied powers that are logically connected with express powers
3. powers essential to the local government purpose
* used to attack a local rule as void
1. delegated powers from legislature
2. implied powers that are logically connected with express powers
3. powers essential to the local government purpose
* used to attack a local rule as void
question
taxing power
answer
state only has INCOME taxing power
...but can require businesses to be licensed and then charge them a tax based on receipts
...but can require businesses to be licensed and then charge them a tax based on receipts
question
local government police powers
answer
authority to act for the health and safety of its people
question
Ordinance validity requirements
answer
1. prior published notice to alert public of likelihood of the ordinance
2. majority vote of the city council and there must be a quorum
3. ordinance must be reasonably certain in application or else not validly adopted
Challenger has BOP
2. majority vote of the city council and there must be a quorum
3. ordinance must be reasonably certain in application or else not validly adopted
Challenger has BOP
question
Common ordinance validity challenges
answer
- not properly adopted
- unconstitutionally vague
- discriminatory without government purpose
- not in authority of the local government (Dylan's Rule)
- preempted by state law
- unconstitutionally vague
- discriminatory without government purpose
- not in authority of the local government (Dylan's Rule)
- preempted by state law
question
Preemption by State Statutes
answer
FOUR inconsistencies
1. state prohibition of the activity then local authorization barred
2. state authorization of an activity that local law forbids - local ordinance is void and unenforceable
3. state law is silent - local ordinance may regulate or prohibit if it is within the authorized powers of the locality
4. some state regulation - S Ct says if state law regulates a topic then a local ordinance may also regulate the topic as long as it is consistent with state law
1. state prohibition of the activity then local authorization barred
2. state authorization of an activity that local law forbids - local ordinance is void and unenforceable
3. state law is silent - local ordinance may regulate or prohibit if it is within the authorized powers of the locality
4. some state regulation - S Ct says if state law regulates a topic then a local ordinance may also regulate the topic as long as it is consistent with state law
question
Zoning Law Procedure
answer
- delegated power from state to local gov
- passed in local council meetings
- ordinance states where it is located on a map and then defines its purpose
- passed in local council meetings
- ordinance states where it is located on a map and then defines its purpose
question
zoning administrator
answer
job is to enforce ordinance or allow request for something not clearly allowed
question
board of zoning appeals
answer
quasi-judicial set up by locality and commonly has authority to interpret ordinance and rule/grand an exception or a variance
-- some local governments allow them to grant special use permits
-- some local governments allow them to grant special use permits
question
appealing Board of Zoning ruling
answer
Appeal to Circuit Court within 30 days; file a writ showing BZA applied incorrect legal rules or ruling was in error to any fact finding or sufficiency of fact
question
planning commission
answer
appointed group that conducts public hearing as to zoning ordinance and map amendments and makes recommendations to the government bodies
question
Standard for granting variation ordinance
answer
1. strict enforcement causes undue hardship to you as a landowner
2. if variant granted, it will not be detrimental to your neighbor
2. if variant granted, it will not be detrimental to your neighbor
question
Conditional Zoning
answer
Proffer: if you change this zoning law then I will do this for the local government
If allowed, it is an enforceable contract in government court
If allowed, it is an enforceable contract in government court
question
Grandfathering Zoning Laws
answer
You can use the grandfather provision if:
1. locality makes a significant affirmative act furthering your planned use for the property;
2. landowner relies in good faith on that act; and
3. the land owner must incur substantial monetary or other obligations
1. locality makes a significant affirmative act furthering your planned use for the property;
2. landowner relies in good faith on that act; and
3. the land owner must incur substantial monetary or other obligations
question
Government contract authority and approval
answer
- Must enter into Ks only within their authority; generally if you have the authority to perform an activity then you can buy things related to that activity (ex: school buying necessities)
- then governing bodies must approve contractual action or else there may be a contractual defect
- then governing bodies must approve contractual action or else there may be a contractual defect
question
VA Freedom of Information Act
answer
- all public records open to inspection or copying by any journalist or citizen by request UNLESS specific exclusion;
- government must respond to request within 5 days
- if no response within 5 days automatic violation of law
(statute is pro-disclosure)
- government must respond to request within 5 days
- if no response within 5 days automatic violation of law
(statute is pro-disclosure)
question
What can VA FOIA never exclude
answer
1. contracts between public entities and government
2. non-exempt portions of consulting reports
2. non-exempt portions of consulting reports
question
What happens if a public meeting of government officials closes midsession for an executive session?
answer
Each member must publicly certify that only confidential information was being discussed (actual/probate litigation; hiring; property negotiations)
question
County Tort Immunity
answer
absolutely immune
question
VA Tort Claim Act
answer
allows you to sue the state for up to $100,000 but provides immunity to cities, towns, and counties
question
City and Town Tort Immunity
answer
- can only sue for proprietary actions, not governmental actions
*If even a little governmental action then it becomes all immune
*If even a little governmental action then it becomes all immune
question
Proprietary actions
answer
promote the comfort, safety, welfare of citizens
(road maintenance, utility services, operation of municipal housing authority)
(road maintenance, utility services, operation of municipal housing authority)
question
Governmental Action
answer
if the function is exercise of entities' political, discretionary, or legislative authority
question
Broad Government Employee Immunity Steps
answer
1. Is the entity immune? If no, then no immunity. If yes, then go on.
2. Can you sue the employee? (Four Step Test)
2. Can you sue the employee? (Four Step Test)
question
Test for Suing a Government Employee (Sovereign Immunity)
answer
1. can be liable based on the nature of their function - if proprietary probably not covered, if government action then probably is
2. the extent of government's interest in the function (if high then likely to be immune)
3. degree of control exercised by governmental authority (if high then likely to be immune)
4. whether alleged wrongful act involves exercise of judgment and discretion (if yes then probably immune)
2. the extent of government's interest in the function (if high then likely to be immune)
3. degree of control exercised by governmental authority (if high then likely to be immune)
4. whether alleged wrongful act involves exercise of judgment and discretion (if yes then probably immune)
question
School Sovereign Immunity
answer
teacher, school boards, administrators, and bus drivers have automatic immunity
question
Public Recreational Facilities Sovereign Immunity
answer
only liable for gross and wanton negligence in the facility - P must show, high standard
question
Driving Situations Sovereign Immunity
answer
Police/Firefighters responding to a call are governmental, but if not responding to a call/no emergency then no immunity
question
Government Employees Sued for Gross Negligence or Intentional Torts - Sovereign Immunity
answer
locality may not be sued
employee can be sued - no immunity
employee can be sued - no immunity
question
Contract Liability - Sovereign Immunity
answer
If counties/cities/towns breach contracts then claim must be presented by party claiming breach
They must go and ask again for repair to the breach 30 days later and if the government body says they won't pay, P can appeal to the Circuit Court within 6 months of being disallowed
*Complaint to Cir. Court must state that P went through procedure and was denied
They must go and ask again for repair to the breach 30 days later and if the government body says they won't pay, P can appeal to the Circuit Court within 6 months of being disallowed
*Complaint to Cir. Court must state that P went through procedure and was denied
question
Procedure for Tort/Negligence Claims Against Local Government
answer
- written notice given to chief attorney within the city/town/county or chief governmental executive (mayor) within 6 months of the action unless P in a coma or something
- any form of delivery permitted
- signed US Mail receipt is prima facie evidence of delivery
- any form of delivery permitted
- signed US Mail receipt is prima facie evidence of delivery
question
Nuisance Claims against City/Town
answer
- nuisance if conditions in an authorized activity negligently creates a dangerous situation
- localities are liable if activity causing nuisance was unauthorized by law
- same 6 month procedure applies
- localities are liable if activity causing nuisance was unauthorized by law
- same 6 month procedure applies
question
SOL effect on state/local government
answer
SOL applies on local municipalities but doesn't apply to the Commonwealth
question
Eminent Domain
answer
-governmental body may exercise power after proper proceeding if two things happen:
1. public need for property, which must be declared in the resolution or ordinance directing the condemnation AND
2. condemner having made a good faith offer of purchase cannot agree with the owner as to the compensation to be paid to the owner
GOV has BOP
1. public need for property, which must be declared in the resolution or ordinance directing the condemnation AND
2. condemner having made a good faith offer of purchase cannot agree with the owner as to the compensation to be paid to the owner
GOV has BOP
question
Standard for Eminent Domain
answer
public interest must dominate over private financial gain AND cannot create additional tax revenue for local government
question
Condemnation/Eminent Domain Statutory Procedure
answer
- Brought in circuit court; fact finders are jurors or commissioners
- recovery is the fair market value of the property PLUS lost profits and damage due to lost access
- affect or residual property - adverse effect on the property owner's remaining property can also be collected
- recovery is the fair market value of the property PLUS lost profits and damage due to lost access
- affect or residual property - adverse effect on the property owner's remaining property can also be collected
question
Inverse condemnation
answer
Local government makes surrounding property less valuable or causes damage
- can bring suit
- can bring suit
question
Local Government Right to Adverse Possession
answer
same rules as normal
question
Local Government Sale of Public Property
answer
-Sale must be based on local ordinance/resolution passed with 3/4th vote of governing body of municipality
- Leases of real property can't be for longer than 40 years
- Leases of real property can't be for longer than 40 years